I was interested in reading The Shadow of the Crescent Moon even before it was made the Long List for the Bailey’s Prize simply because it is by Fatima Bhutto. The Bhutto family is to Pakistan what the Kennedy family is to the United States; a prime political family of privilege scarred by tragedy.
I loved the way in which The Shadow of the Crescent Moon was told. Over the course of a single morning, Bhutto relates the story of three brothers and the different paths they have taken, as well as the recent history of Waziristan‘s bid for separation/ Independence. The experiences of the three brothers show how fraught and complex the question of Waziristan really is. Squeezed in between Afghanistan and the rest of Pakistan, it is at the heart of much of the political turmoil in the region, while also involved in its own battles.
My one criticism about the novel, and the reason why I think it was not popular with wider audiences, is that it alludes to the the various factions in Waziristan and their relationships to Pakistan and Afghanistan without spelling it all out in an obvious way. I think many readers not familiar with the region may need a little more information to truly understand the import of what Bhutto is saying.
Who would like this book? The Shadow of the Crescent Moon is a political novel that tells a cracking story. I really enjoyed the subtlety of its telling, but as I mentioned, that too may be a drawback. I really recommend it for people who are interested in the region and the politics that transcend national borders. It would also pair nicely with The Blind Man’s Garden (review).
I received a copy of this book for review consideration from the publisher via NetGalley.
I was curious about this book, so I’m glad to see you enjoyed it! I feel like most of what I’ve read from the region has been nonfiction, so it would be nice to mix things up a little.
I had heard some so-so things about it, but I’m really glad I read it. I think the so-so things may have come from the fact that there are a lot of shades of grey in it, when people want clear cut answers and a clear good guy vs. bad guy.
I remember seeing this book on Edelweiss and was curious about it. I’m glad you liked it! I think this book would definitely take me down the Wikipedia wormhole.
Definitely.
Did your galley have a lot of errors in it? I tried to read this and there were 2-3 errors every swipe of the Kindle. I gave up pretty early on.
Yes, but the errors made me laugh. Back in the old days galleys were always riddled with major mistakes.
I loved The Blind Man’s Garden! That was one that was a hit or miss for so many as well. Seeing that comparison though has me adding The Shadow of the Crescent Moon to my list!
I didn’t love The Blind Man’s Garden. But there are enough similarities in terms of setting and politics.
Oh! Ha! I had already added it to my TBR!
I’ll be interested to see if it makes Baileys short list on Monday. Thanks for the review.
Didn’t make the list, too bad. I was shocked to see Sarah Waters on it, as I didn’t think it was as good as her other books. Aside from that, I’ve only read the Shamsie.
This on my to-read list and since I know nothing about the setting, I’m happy to have read your review first. I’ll be sure to read a bit about Waziristan before I start this one 🙂
I really did enjoy it.