The Mountain Shadow by Gregory David Roberts

the mountain shadow by Gregory David RobertsThe Shadow Mountain is Gregory David Roberts‘ much anticipated follow-up to Shantarambut for me, it fell short of Shantaram in everything but length, if you can imagine that. It picks up on the story where Shantaram left off, so in theory it should be just as captivating, but instead it left me wondering if Shantaram was really all that great. That being said, I still read all 912 pages of it.

Where do I begin? How about our protagonist Shantaram? In this book he seems to vacillate between trying to show us that he is as bad-ass as ever, while also getting bogged down in his obsession with Karla and waxing philosophical intensely for pages on end. I think he wants to be the bad-ass action hero, who can love and is a philosopher at heart. Unfortunately that means we end up with long passages about gangster life in Bombay complete with crazy fight scenes followed by philosophical discourses that go on and on. This is all bracketed by him waxing poetic about life and love at the beginning and end of every chapter.

My other complaint about The Shadow Mountain is that Shantaram seems to have been seduced by the good life. One of the things I loved about Shantaram was how Roberts wrote about life for the downtrodden, whether they were strung out foreigners or Indian slum dwellers. In this book, Roberts cleans everything up. We are dealing mostly with well-off expats living the high life in Bombay with the addition of a Bombay princess. Even our street dwelling druggies come into a crazy inheritance that takes them into the lap of luxury.

Who would like this book? Well, if you loved Shantaram there is a good chance you’re going to read this book regardless of what I say and I would do exactly the same thing. But if you’re not a fan of Shantaram, there is no reason for you to pick up this brick of a book. At this point I don’t even know if I’d recommend Shantaram. I mean, it was good and I liked it, but it was also pretty schlocky at times.

Advertisements

6 Comments

  1. I felt exactly the same way you did. I wish I hadn’t read ‘The Mountain Shadow’ as it also led me to question whether ‘Shantaram’ was as good as I remembered it to be. Now I’ve had time to reflect I’m convinced that ‘Shantaram’ is an amazing book and this one is terrible. Such a shame.

  2. I’d been wavering about this. I sort of liked Shantaram but in places it was a bit up itself for me and I thought it ran out of steam a little towards the end. I was intrigued enough to think about reading Mountain Shadow but having read your review, probably not intrigued enough!

  3. Tanya,I couldn’t agree with your review more! After lots of initial excitement about this one I felt so disappointed really early on. I remembered that Shantarm wasn’t amazingly written but the plot was great but there was nothing good about the sequel.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s